The Pros and Cons of Self-Management vs. Hiring a Property Manager

Self Made: NASE's Blog

Blog With Us

Welcome to the Self Made. This is a blog focused primarily on the self-employed and micro-business and full of fantastic posts by not only our team of experts but by YOU!  We realize that there are many ways to help the small businesses out there which is why we invite other business minded individuals to post here and help the rest of the community as well.

The Pros and Cons of Self-Management vs. Hiring a Property Manager

Nov 29, 2023

Embarking on rental property investments offers substantial potential for profit, yet it entails a pivotal choice: should you personally oversee your properties or enlist the services of a property manager? Each approach has its own set of advantages and disadvantages that can significantly impact your investment success. Making the right choice between these two options is paramount to maximizing your returns in the real estate market.

Stay with us as we weigh the pros and cons of self-management versus hiring a property manager to help you make an informed decision for your investment.

Self-Management: Taking Control

Pros of Self-Management:

  • Cost Savings: One of the most significant advantages of self-management is cost savings. When you handle property management tasks yourself, you avoid paying a property management company a percentage of your rental income, which can add up over time.

  • Hands-On Experience: Self-management provides an excellent opportunity to gain hands-on experience in property management. You'll learn the ins and outs of property maintenance, tenant relations, and local rental laws, which can be valuable knowledge for future investments.

  • Control Over Decision-Making: You have complete control over all decisions related to your property, from setting rental rates to choosing tenants. This autonomy allows you to make choices that align with your investment strategy.

  • Direct Tenant Interaction: Self-management enables direct communication with tenants. This can foster better relationships and quicker response times when issues arise.

Cons of Self-Management:

  • Time-Consuming: Managing a property can be time-consuming, especially if you have multiple units or a full-time job. Handling tenant inquiries, maintenance requests, and paperwork can become overwhelming.

  • Limited Expertise: Unless you have experience in property management, you may lack the expertise to handle complex issues effectively. Mistakes can lead to legal and financial consequences.

  • Maintenance Challenges: Dealing with maintenance and repairs can be challenging, particularly if you lack the skills or connections to reliable contractors. Delayed repairs can result in unhappy tenants and potential property damage.

  • Vacancy Risks: Marketing and filling vacancies can be demanding. Extended vacancies can eat into your rental income and affect your return on investment.

Hiring a Property Manager: Outsourcing the Work

Pros of Hiring a Property Manager:

  • Time and Stress Savings: A property manager takes care of day-to-day tasks, freeing up your time and reducing stress. They handle tenant issues, maintenance requests, and rent collection, allowing you to focus on other investments or personal pursuits.

  • Professional Expertise: Property managers are experienced professionals who understand the intricacies of property management, including local laws, regulations, and insurance issues. They can navigate complex situations and help you avoid legal pitfalls.

  • Access to Networks: Property managers often have extensive networks of contractors and service providers. This can result in cost savings and faster resolution of maintenance issues.

  • Marketing and Tenant Screening: Property managers can effectively market your property and screen potential tenants, increasing the likelihood of finding reliable renters and minimizing vacancy periods.

Cons of Hiring a Property Manager:

  • Management Fees: The primary drawback is the cost. Property management fees typically range from 5% to 10% of the rental income, which can eat into your profits.

  • Less Control: When you hire a property manager, you relinquish some control over your investment. While you can still make major decisions, day-to-day operations are handled by the manager.

  • Quality Variance: Not all property management companies are created equal. The quality of service can vary, so it's essential to do thorough research and select a reputable manager.

  • Communication Challenges: Depending on the property manager, you may have limited direct interaction with tenants. This can make it harder to gauge tenant satisfaction and address concerns promptly.

Making the Right Choice

The decision between self-management and hiring a property manager ultimately hinges on your individual circumstances and goals as an investor. Here are some key considerations to help you make the right choice:

  • Time Availability: Assess how much time you can realistically dedicate to property management. If you have a full-time job or other commitments, hiring a property manager may be the practical choice.

  • Experience and Expertise: Consider your level of experience in property management. If you're new to the game, hiring a professional can help you avoid costly mistakes.

  • Property Portfolio Size: The number of properties you own or plan to acquire can influence your decision. Managing a single unit may be manageable, but a larger portfolio can quickly become overwhelming without assistance.

  • Financial Resources: Evaluate your budget financial resources. If you're willing to pay for convenience and expertise, hiring a property manager can be a sensible investment.

  • Local Market Dynamics: Research your local rental market. Some markets may be more landlord-friendly, while others require a deeper understanding of tenant rights and regulations.

  • Personal Preferences: Reflect on your management style and preferences. Some investors enjoy the hands-on approach of self-management, while others prefer the convenience of outsourcing tasks.

Unlocking Success: The Vital Role of Rental Management Companies

A rental management company, often the keystone in property investment, can be the key to a stress-free and profitable real estate venture. These professionals bring a wealth of expertise to the table, navigating the complex landscape of tenant relations, property maintenance, and local regulations with finesse. 

When entrusting your rental properties to a reputable rental management company, you gain access to their extensive networks of contractors and service providers, ensuring that maintenance issues are swiftly addressed, reducing vacancy risks through effective marketing and tenant screening, and allowing you to reclaim precious time for other investments or personal pursuits. 

While there is a cost involved, the peace of mind and potential for enhanced returns make the decision to collaborate with a rental management company a strategic move for many property investors.

Final Thoughts 

Ultimately, the choice between self-management and hiring a property manager is a pivotal one for real estate investors. Both options have their merits and drawbacks, and the decision should align with your investment goals, experience, and available resources. Whether you choose to take control and self-manage or delegate tasks to a property manager, careful consideration and research are key to achieving success in the competitive world of real estate investing.

Meet The Author:

Andrea Johnson

Andrea Johnson

Andrea Johnson is a dynamic Communications Manager and prolific Creative Blogger known for her exceptional ability to bridge the gap between effective corporate communication and engaging content creation. With 4 years of experience in communications and 3 years of dedicated blogging, Andrea brings a unique blend of strategic insight and creative flair to every endeavor. Nonetheless, her hobbies include traveling and design.


The opinions expressed in our published works are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the National Association for the Self-Employed or its members.

Courtesy of